EHRC – UPDATE ON BEHALF OF ANDREW FEINSTEIN AND JUSTIN SCHLOSBERG
Following careful consideration and receipt of counsel opinion, we have decided not to progress our judicial review challenge of the EHRC, in spite of the egregious legal flaws in its report. Under UK law, judicial reviews can only be brought by individuals who are deemed to have what is known as sufficient ‘legal standing’. In this case, we were advised that the Court is highly unlikely to accept an application for judicial review by anyone other than Labour Party itself, or individuals directly named in the EHRC report.
We are, however, encouraged to see that such actions are now being brought by others. We are also currently pursuing alternative routes of redress which we will update on in due course.
We understand that some of you may have donated to Truth Defence exclusively to support a potential legal challenge of the EHRC, rather than our broader related work and campaigns. We are therefore offering anyone who has donated since the announcement of our EHRC challenge the opportunity to claim a proportional refund, less the small amount of legal expenses we have incurred to date. In order to claim a refund, please email firstname.lastname@example.org by no later than 31st January 2021, detailing your full name and refund amount you are claiming.
Truth Defence - EHRC Challenge
The EHRC’s investigation into anti-Semitism in the Labour Party failed to give due consideration and weight to vital evidence it was made aware of. This evidence flatly contradicted some of its key findings, especially in relation to the role of the former leadership under Jeremy Corbyn.
As a result, the report rehashed a dominant and demonstrably false narrative that laid the blame for failures in the handling of complaints with the former leadership. In fact, the evidence overwhelmingly suggests that Corbyn introduced unprecedented and wide ranging reforms that dramatically improved a legacy complaints system that was not fit for purpose. If anything, his efforts to expedite investigations and escalate sanctions were hampered by factionally-motivated staff who were in control of the process until Jennie Formby took over as General Secretary in 2018.
It is vitally important that the EHRC is held to account for its flawed investigation and erroneous conclusions, both to correct the historical record and learn the right lessons from Labour's painful recent past. This is essential not just for the future of the Labour Party but for the fight against antisemitism and all forms of racism everywhere.
We are supporting a group of Jewish members of the party – which include Truth Defence directors and co-founders Justin Schlosberg and Andrew Feinstein – who are seeking to mount a formal legal challenge to the EHRC’s ruling.
Please support our campaign and get regular updates on case progress, costs and outcomes.
Andrew Feinstein on Channel 4 news with Jon Snow
Dr Justin Schlosberg on lbc with iain dale
Dr Justin Schlosberg on Talk Radio